In my
post promoting my
second article for Guns, Holsters, and Gear, commenter Vic asks an excellent question:
So here's a question.
I don't own a gun, I've never owned one, and I've never had formal training. I have, however, been shooting a couple of times and plan to buy a gun in a few months (I'm abroad at the moment and won't be back until the summer). The few times I went shooting, I discovered that while I have fun putting more or less anything downrange, I really, really loved the 1911s and the .357 revolver I shot (I did my best to try as many of the 9mm plastics for comparison and tried the 1911s on a whim). I'm now torn as to whether I should stick with a smaller caliber for the first gun, or just buy a 1911 and learn on that.
What do you think? I don't think I need to be "hooked" (I'm totally there, the only reason I wasn't at the range every day this summer was that it costs money and that you need a buddy to rent a lane if you don't own a gun), but I'm definitely a long way from any kind of competency.
Man, that's a tough call. I love the 1911 platform in (almost) all of its incarnations (that LDA trigger is an abomination unto John Moses Browning, PBUH), but I'm also an unabashed wheelgun fan. I carry a 1911 in the winter and a J-frame pretty much year round, and have been known to carry a 3" K-frame from time to time as well. .45 ACP and .357 Magnum are both capable defensive calibers, with the 1911 having the edge in capacity but the .357 Magnum having the edge in versatility (given that a revolver chambered in .357 Magnum will also fire the .38 Special cartridge).
Many factors influence the response here.
A quality .357 Magnum revolver can be found used for $300 - $400 and new for about double that; 1911s vary greatly from Rock Island Armory or AutoOrdnance for around $500 to, well,
$65K (okay, that might be an outlier, but a custom 1911 can easily run well into quality used car area for price). Ammo prices are fairly comparable - .45 ACP runs between $15 and $20 for a box of 50 rounds, .38 Special/.357 Magnum about the same.
- What's the intended purpose?
Concealed carry? Target shooting? General plinking? A Commander-sized 1911 might be suitable for all three purposes; ditto a 3" barrel model 386. A Smith & Wesson model 60 (or the Snubbie from Hell™ model 360) is more concealable under more conditions; a 5" Government Colt is more accurate and has higher capacity, so as a target gun or for home defense might get the edge. For hunting a 6" barrel .357 Magnum would work better than most anything available on the 1911 platform. If the purpose is a general, good for all three gun, then a Commander 1911 or 3" Night Guard might work (or a 4" Model 19, for that matter).
- How much tinkering do you like to do?
The 1911 wins here, hands down. The revolver has the option of changing out the grips, lightening the trigger, and maybe changing out the sights. The 1911 has an entire industry devoted to aftermarket parts. If you're the sort who wants to customize your handgun, the 1911 certainly has more options; on the other hand, if you just want to take it out of the box and make it go bang, the wheelgun might work better for your needs. Another consideration for the 1911 is that you can get a conversion kit for it and be able to shoot .22LR through it - making for cheap plinking costs but still being able to use it as a defensive arm with the original barrel and slide.
It's a difficult question, that's for certain. Part of me is tempted to punt and say get both - look for a generic .357 Magnum wheelie as well as an entry-level 1911. It's hard to recommend one or the other - for general plinking they're both just fun, outstanding guns. If the only criteria is "something to take to the range and have fun", well, grab a handful of cash and go to the gun store. See what jumps out at you. You really can't lose.
If pressed to make an absolute choice between the two, I'd opt for a 4" barrel Smith & Wesson model 19 or 686 or Ruger GP100. A medium frame .357 Magnum revolver is a swiss army knife type of gun - stoke it with Cowboy Action .38 Special loads for light plinking or taking a new shooter to the range for their first centerfire handgun; stoke it with 158 grain .357 Magnum rounds for self-defense. They're easier to clean and require less maintenance than their semi-automatic counterparts, and still yield plenty of punch on the naughty end.
What would you recommend - 1911 semi-automatic or .357 Magnum revolver?That is all.